J the App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPostsDownload App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPosts
Download App
Terms|Privacy

JustIDT Solutions Private Limited © 2026

  1. Home
  2. Posts
  3. Direct Tax
  4. Bombay HC says Section 41(2) Loss Claim Restricted to Specified Power Undertakings
Corporate TaxArticle·17 November 2026

Bombay HC says Section 41(2) Loss Claim Restricted to Specified Power Undertakings

By J the App

Executive Summary

Everest Kanto Cylinder Ltd., engaged in manufacturing and exporting CNG cylinders, claimed a loss of ₹56.79 lakh on the sale of depreciable fixed assets under Section 41(2). The Tribunal had rejected the claim on the ground that the provision applies only to undertakings engaged in generation or generation and distribution of power, which claim depreciation on the straight-line method. The Bombay High Court agreed. Tracing the legislative history of Section 41(2), the Court explained that the provision was reintroduced in 1998 with limited application following the shift to the block-of-assets depreciation system. For other assessees, sale proceeds are adjusted against the WDV of the relevant block under Section 43(6), with the capital gains provisions governing the consequences where applicable. The assessee's appeal was dismissed.

Domain | Direct Tax | Corporate Tax | Depreciation |Sections 32, 41(2), 43(6) and 50

T...

Read the full article in the app

This is a premium article. Download J the App to read the complete content.

Read in the App

Get the full experience with comments, likes, and more in the app.

Open in App
App StoreGoogle Play