J the App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPostsDownload App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPosts
Download App
Terms|Privacy

JustIDT Solutions Private Limited © 2026

  1. Home
  2. Posts
  3. Indirect Tax
  4. CESTAT Says Royalty Forms Part of Coal Value but Stowing Duty Excluded
Legacy TaxesArticle·20 November 2026

CESTAT Says Royalty Forms Part of Coal Value but Stowing Duty Excluded

By J the App

Executive Summary

The Mumbai CESTAT has drawn a distinction between royalty and Stowing Excise Duty while determining the assessable value of coal. Following the Supreme Court's ruling that royalty is contractual consideration and not a tax, the Tribunal held that royalty forms part of the transaction value. However, SED, being a specific levy of excise duty under the Coal Mines (Conservation and Development) Act, is excludible. The extended period, penalties and redemption fines were set aside, while the royalty demand for the normal period, together with interest, was sustained.

Domain | Legacy taxes | IDT | Central Excise | Valuation | Limitation

The Position

Read the full article in the app

This is a premium article. Download J the App to read the complete content.

Read in the App

Get the full experience with comments, likes, and more in the app.

Open in App
App StoreGoogle Play