J the App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPostsDownload App
HomeWhat We DoFeaturesPosts
Download App
Terms|Privacy

JustIDT Solutions Private Limited © 2026

  1. Home
  2. Posts
  3. Indirect Tax
  4. GSTAT Prayagraj says One-Day Sales Cannot Justify Extrapolated Turnover for Nine Months
Goods and Service TaxArticle·18 November 2026

GSTAT Prayagraj says One-Day Sales Cannot Justify Extrapolated Turnover for Nine Months

By J the App

Executive Summary

Grace Book Centre challenged a demand of ₹3,10,290 based on a survey conducted on 31 March 2018, where sales of approximately ₹70,000 were recorded. The Department extrapolated this figure through a uniform monthly turnover of ₹1.67 lakh for nine months, without reconciling the estimate with the taxpayer's books or returns. GSTAT held that a single day's sales, particularly on the eve of the academic session when book sales are seasonal, could not support such extrapolation. It also found that the show cause notice failed to establish fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression with intent to evade tax, as required under Section 74. The Tribunal set aside the entire demand, including interest and penalty, without remanding the matter.

Domain | Indirect Tax | GST | Assessment, Suppression and Demand Quantification

The Po...

Read the full article in the app

This is a premium article. Download J the App to read the complete content.

Read in the App

Get the full experience with comments, likes, and more in the app.

Open in App
App StoreGoogle Play